Travel, camping and long drives
Cassette toilet or portable toilet?
Choose a cassette toilet if your motorhome, caravan or van has room for a fixed toilet and a service door in the wall: you take the cassette out from outside and wheel it to the disposal point. Choose a portable toilet such as a Thetford Porta Potti or Dometic 970 if you need to move it, store it in a cupboard, use it in a tent or boat, or cannot cut a door in the wall. It needs no fitting, but you carry the whole waste tank out by hand.
Last reviewed
Affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, toiletnearest.com earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and stock are on Amazon and change often, so check them there. How we choose products.

How each works
Both kinds are chemical toilets: a bowl with a flush above a sealed waste tank, with an additive in the tank to control smell. The difference is how the tank gets out.
A cassette toilet is fixed in place in the washroom of a motorhome, campervan or caravan. Thetford describes it as a permanently installed toilet with a flushing system and a removable waste-holding tank, the cassette, which you reach from outside through a service door. The flush comes either from the toilet's own small tank, filled through a filler door outside, or from the vehicle's main water tank.
A portable toilet is a free-standing box in two halves: a flush-water tank and bowl on top, the waste tank below, with a blade (a sliding valve) between them. Thetford says its Porta Potti needs no drain, water or power connection. To empty it, you unclip the halves and carry the bottom one away.
Side by side
Two cassette toilets and two portable toilets, as representatives of each kind. Metric figures are the makers'; imperial ones are the makers' where they give them, and our conversions otherwise.
| Thetford C220 cassette toilet | Dometic CTW 4110 cassette toilet | Thetford Porta Potti 365 | Dometic 976 portable toilet | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | Compact built-in cassette toilet | Cassette toilet with a ceramic bowl | Portable toilet with a pump flush | Portable toilet with a push-button flush |
| Type | Built in, cassette removed from outside | Built in, cassette removed from outside | Free-standing, two parts | Free-standing, two parts |
| Waste tank | 18 l (4.8 gal) | 19 l (5.0 gal) | 21 l (5.5 gal) | 18.9 l (5.0 gal) |
| Flush water | Vehicle's water tank (electric versions) or its own 9 l (2.4 gal) tank (manual version) | Its own 7 l (1.8 gal) tank | Its own 15 l (4 gal) tank | Its own 8.7 l (2.3 gal) tank |
| Flush | Electric or manual, by version | Electric, 12 V | Piston pump | Push button, after pumping up pressure |
| Size (H x W x D) | 495 to 727 x 365 to 394 x 580 mm (19.5 to 28.6 x 14.4 to 15.5 x 22.8 in), by version | 672 x 382 x 530 mm (26.5 x 15.0 x 20.9 in) | 414 x 383 x 427 mm (16.29 x 15.07 x 16.81 in) | 387 x 333 x 387 mm (15 1/4 x 13 1/8 x 15 1/4 in) |
| Seat height | 492 mm (19.4 in) | Not stated | 408 mm (16.06 in) | 387 mm (15.25 in) |
| Net weight | 6.8 to 8.0 kg (15.0 to 17.6 lb), by version | 12.25 kg (27.0 lb) | 4.0 kg (8.8 lb) | 4.99 kg (11.0 lb) |
| Level indicator | Waste, one level | Display; empty as soon as possible at 75% | Waste tank | Waste tank |
| Emptying | Through a service door outside; cassette on wheels | Through a service door outside | Lift off the top, carry the waste tank | Lift off the top, carry the waste tank |
| Price | Check price on Amazon: Thetford C220 cassette toilet (affiliate link, opens in a new tab) | Check price on Amazon: Dometic CTW 4110 cassette toilet (affiliate link, opens in a new tab) | Check price on Amazon: Thetford Porta Potti 365 (affiliate link, opens in a new tab) | Check price on Amazon: Dometic 976 portable toilet (affiliate link, opens in a new tab) |
Space and fitting
A cassette toilet takes a permanent corner of the vehicle, plus a hole in the outside wall for the service door. Dometic says its CT 4000 cassette toilets are for campervans, motor caravans and caravans, and must be installed by qualified personnel. If your vehicle already has one, Thetford says a cassette toilet can be replaced in most situations, so changing models is usually easier than adding one where there was none.
A portable toilet only needs floor space. The ones here are about 39 to 41 cm (15 to 16 in) high, and the Dometic 976 is the narrowest at 333 mm (13 1/8 in) wide. To stop one sliding about while you drive, Thetford sells an optional hold-down kit for the Porta Potti 365, and Dometic sells a fastening kit for the 970 series. Its 974 and 975 come with mounting brackets.
Height matters for comfort. The C220's seat is 492 mm (19.4 in) from the floor. On the portable toilets it is lower: 408 mm (16.06 in) on the Porta Potti 365 and 387 mm (15.25 in) on the Dometic 976. If you want a taller portable, the Porta Potti 565E has a 443 mm (17.44 in) seat; see the Porta Potti vs Dometic 970 comparison for every size in both ranges.
Capacity and how often you empty
The waste tanks are closer in size than you might expect. The cassettes here hold 18 litres (C220) and 19 litres (CTW 4110), and Thetford's other cassettes hold 17.5 litres (C260) and 19.3 litres (C400). Portable toilets range from 9.8 litres (2.6 gal) in the Dometic 972 to 21 litres (5.5 gal) in the Porta Potti 365 and 565. Guidance for campervan sites in Scotland takes a typical black-water tank as 20 litres (5.3 gal), including rinse water.
- Cassettes: Thetford says to empty one when it is full or starts to smell, which with its additives is every 4 to 5 days with its Blue products and 3 to 4 days with Green. Dometic says to empty its CT 4000 cassettes as soon as possible once the display shows 75%.
- Portables: Thetford's US help pages say a full waste tank comes after about 27 to 33 flushes, depending on the model. Dometic says the 970's 8.7-litre flush tank is enough for 27 flushes.
- Either way: Thetford says not to travel with a tank more than three-quarters full, or with water in the bowl.
Emptying
This is where the two kinds differ most. With a cassette, you open the service door outside, pull the cassette out and, on Thetford models, wheel it to the disposal point with its handle. Nothing comes back through the van.
With a portable toilet, you close the blade, unclip the bottom half and carry it out through the vehicle or tent. A full 21-litre tank holds about 21 kg (46 lb) of liquid on top of the tank itself, so a smaller tank emptied more often can suit someone who cannot lift much. Both kinds pour the same way: spout up to take the cap off, then spout down low over the drain with a thumb on the vent button.
Both go only to a chemical disposal point (an Elsan point in the UK, a dump station in North America and Australia), or a toilet on the mains sewer where that is allowed. Our step-by-step guide on how to empty a cassette or chemical toilet covers where you can and cannot empty one in the UK, the US and Australia.
Smell and chemicals
Both kinds use the same products. A waste-tank additive goes into the tank with enough water to cover the bottom, and a rinse additive goes into the flush water. The catch is a cassette toilet that flushes from the vehicle's main water tank: you cannot add a rinse additive to your drinking water, so Thetford sells a bowl spray for those toilets instead.
Smell usually means the tank needs emptying, or the seal around the blade needs cleaning and lubricating. Thetford says to use a seal lubricant, and to replace a cassette's lip seal after 4 to 6 years. Some campsites only allow green, formaldehyde-free chemicals; see the best toilet chemicals for which products are which.
Which suits your layout
- Motorhome or caravan with a washroom: a cassette toilet, which it probably has already. Emptying from outside is the main gain.
- Campervan conversion with no washroom: a portable toilet that lives in a cupboard or under a seat, fixed down with a hold-down or fastening kit. Measure the space with the lid up.
- Tent, awning, camper trailer or small boat: a portable toilet. Thetford says its Porta Potti is often used in all of these.
- Someone who cannot lift a full tank: a cassette on wheels, or a smaller portable such as the Dometic 972 or Porta Potti 335 emptied more often.
Settled on a portable? Our guide to the best portable camping toilets compares eight, and Porta Potti vs Dometic 970 takes the two best-known ranges model by model. On the road, our toilet map shows public toilets near you, so you can save the tank for when you need it.
The composting alternative
A separating (often called composting) toilet sends liquid and solids to different containers and uses no water or chemicals. The solids are covered with an absorbent material such as sawdust. It suits a van that is often away from disposal points, but you still need somewhere to put each part. On the canals of England and Wales, the Canal & River Trust says the liquid can go down an Elsan and the solids should be composted, and that its bins have not taken bagged toilet waste since December 2021.
The toilets compared
1. Compact built-in cassette toilet
Thetford C220 cassette toilet
Thetford's compact cassette toilet for campervans and motorhomes, made in three versions: with or without its own flush-water tank and console, and with a manual or electric flush. The 18-litre cassette has wheels and a handle, and the bowl turns 90 degrees either way to suit the washroom.
- Type
- Built in, cassette removed from outside
- Waste tank
- 18 l (4.8 gal)
- Flush water
- Vehicle's water tank (electric versions) or its own 9 l (2.4 gal) tank (manual version)
- Flush
- Electric or manual, by version
- Size (H x W x D)
- 495 to 727 x 365 to 394 x 580 mm (19.5 to 28.6 x 14.4 to 15.5 x 22.8 in), by version
- Seat height
- 492 mm (19.4 in)
- Net weight
- 6.8 to 8.0 kg (15.0 to 17.6 lb), by version
- Level indicator
- Waste, one level
- Emptying
- Through a service door outside; cassette on wheels
Good
- Emptied from outside, so the tank never comes through the living space
- Cassette has wheels and a pull-out handle
- Bowl turns 90 degrees either way to fit the layout
Bear in mind
- Has to be built in, with a service door in the vehicle wall
- Plastic bowl
- The level indicator shows one level only
Check price on Amazon: Thetford C220 cassette toilet (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)Specs: Thetford: C220 series
2. Cassette toilet with a ceramic bowl
Dometic CTW 4110 cassette toilet
A swivel-bowl cassette toilet with its own 7-litre flush tank and a ceramic inlay in the bowl, which Dometic says makes it 30% lighter than all-ceramic toilets. Its sister model, the CTS 4110, is the same size and flushes from the vehicle's water tank instead.
- Type
- Built in, cassette removed from outside
- Waste tank
- 19 l (5.0 gal)
- Flush water
- Its own 7 l (1.8 gal) tank
- Flush
- Electric, 12 V
- Size (H x W x D)
- 672 x 382 x 530 mm (26.5 x 15.0 x 20.9 in)
- Net weight
- 12.25 kg (27.0 lb)
- Level indicator
- Display; empty as soon as possible at 75%
- Emptying
- Through a service door outside
Good
- Ceramic inlay in the bowl
- Seat and bowl swivel up to 90 degrees either way
- Its own flush tank keeps the flush water apart from the drinking water
Bear in mind
- Dometic says it must be installed by qualified personnel
- Needs 12 V power for the flush
- Heaviest toilet here, at 12.25 kg
Check price on Amazon: Dometic CTW 4110 cassette toilet (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)Specs: Dometic: CTW 4110 (UK)
3. Portable toilet with a pump flush
Thetford Porta Potti 365
Thetford's large piston-pump Porta Potti: a 21-litre waste tank under a 15-litre flush tank, with a level indicator on the waste tank. It needs no water, power or drain connection, and a kit to fix it to the floor is optional.
- Type
- Free-standing, two parts
- Waste tank
- 21 l (5.5 gal)
- Flush water
- Its own 15 l (4 gal) tank
- Flush
- Piston pump
- Size (H x W x D)
- 414 x 383 x 427 mm (16.29 x 15.07 x 16.81 in)
- Seat height
- 408 mm (16.06 in)
- Net weight
- 4.0 kg (8.8 lb)
- Level indicator
- Waste tank
- Emptying
- Lift off the top, carry the waste tank
Good
- No fitting, power or plumbing
- Largest waste tank here
- Thetford says every model works with a 120 kg (265 lb) load
Bear in mind
- You carry the full tank out by hand
- No level indicator on the flush tank
- Hold-down kit is an extra
Check price on Amazon: Thetford Porta Potti 365 (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)Specs: Thetford: Porta Potti specifications 2025 (PDF)
4. Portable toilet with a push-button flush
Dometic 976 portable toilet
The tall model in Dometic's 970 series. You pump the top tank up to pressure and flush with a button; Dometic's leaflet says one charge lasts 4 to 5 flushes, with no batteries. The waste tank holds 18.9 litres and has a level indicator.
- Type
- Free-standing, two parts
- Waste tank
- 18.9 l (5.0 gal)
- Flush water
- Its own 8.7 l (2.3 gal) tank
- Flush
- Push button, after pumping up pressure
- Size (H x W x D)
- 387 x 333 x 387 mm (15 1/4 x 13 1/8 x 15 1/4 in)
- Seat height
- 387 mm (15.25 in)
- Net weight
- 4.99 kg (11.0 lb)
- Level indicator
- Waste tank
- Emptying
- Lift off the top, carry the waste tank
Good
- Push-button flush with no batteries
- Extra-long pivoting spout for emptying
- Optional fastening kit to fix it to the floor
Bear in mind
- Smaller flush tank than the Porta Potti
- You carry the full tank out by hand
Check price on Amazon: Dometic 976 portable toilet (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)Specs: Dometic: 976 (UK)
Questions
Can I fit a cassette toilet myself?
Dometic says its CT 4000 cassette toilets must be installed by qualified personnel. A cassette toilet needs a service door cut into the vehicle wall so the cassette can come out, and a water supply for the flush unless it has its own tank. Thetford says a cassette toilet can be replaced in most situations, so swapping one cassette toilet for another is usually simpler than adding one.
How often do you empty a cassette toilet?
When the level indicator says so, or when it starts to smell. Thetford says that with its additives a cassette lasts 4 to 5 days with its Blue products and 3 to 4 days with its Green ones. Two people will fill it faster than one.
Is a cassette toilet bigger than a portable toilet?
The waste tanks are similar. The cassettes here hold 18 and 19 litres, and Thetford's C260 and C400 hold 17.5 and 19.3 litres. Portable toilets run from 9.8 litres (the Dometic 972) to 21 litres (the Porta Potti 365 and 565). The cassette toilet itself is larger and is fixed in place.
Can I use a portable toilet in a tent or on a boat?
Yes. Thetford says its Porta Potti is often used in tents, folding tents, camper trailers and boats, and Dometic describes the 970 series as perfect for smaller vehicles and tents. Both need a disposal point to empty them.
Do both kinds need chemicals?
Yes. Both makers say to put a waste-tank additive and a little water in the waste tank, and a rinse additive in the flush tank if the toilet has its own. A toilet that flushes from the vehicle's water tank cannot take a rinse additive; Thetford sells a bowl spray for those.