Skip to main content
toiletnearest.com Search Open the map

Travel, camping and long drives

Disposable urine bags or a reusable travel urinal?

A gel bag is the better emergency kit: it is flat and light, and turns urine into a gel you seal and bin, with nothing to wash. A reusable urinal is better if you go often, in a van or a tent at night: no bags to keep buying, but you empty it into a toilet and wash it. In a car, use either only after you have stopped somewhere safe.

Last reviewed

Affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, toiletnearest.com earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and stock are on Amazon and change often, so check them there. How we choose products.

A white plastic urinal bottle for men with a cap on a cord, lying on a flower-patterned cloth beside its old paper sales label
A plastic urinal bottle for men, made in East Germany, with its original sales label. Photo: Ulf.johannes, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped.

Side by side

Three single-use gel bags and two reusable urinals, one for men and one for women, compared on what their makers publish. Where a maker gives no figure, the table says so.

Disposable urine bags and reusable travel urinals, compared on the makers' published specs
TravelJohn Resealable Disposable Urinalroadbag Disposable UrinalRestop 1 Liquid Waste BagCarex Male UrinalBoom LoonaGo Portable Female Urinal
Best forBest all-round gel bagBiggest bag, for men and boysBest bag with a one-way valveBest reusable bottle for menBest reusable urinal for women
TypeSingle-use gel bagSingle-use gel bagSingle-use gel bagReusable bottleReusable female urinal
Capacity800cc (28 fl oz)1,000 ml (about 34 fl oz)20 oz (about 590 ml)Marks up to 32 fl oz (about 950 ml)24 oz (about 710 ml)
WhoUnisex adapter, sitting or standingMen and boysMen or women: wide opening, semi-rigid rimMenWomen
Spill controlGel pouch, spill guard and resealable zipSuper-absorbent turns urine into a firm gelOne-way valve; polymers and enzymes gel the urineAttached snap-on lidSnap-lock lid
Size5 x 2 x 1 in folded (about 13 x 5 x 2.5 cm)12 x 7 x 1 cm (about 4.7 x 2.8 x 0.4 in)Not statedNot stated4 x 7 x 3 in (about 10 x 18 x 8 cm)
Weight1.5 oz before use (about 43 g)44 g (about 1.6 oz)Not statedNot statedNot stated
After useZip it shut and put it in a binIn the carry bag supplied, then household wasteAny bin, says RestopEmpty into a toilet, then washEmpty into a toilet, rinse, let it dry before locking the lid
PriceCheck price on Amazon: TravelJohn Resealable Disposable Urinal (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)Check price on Amazon: roadbag Disposable Urinal (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)Check price on Amazon: Restop 1 Liquid Waste Bag (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)Check price on Amazon: Carex Male Urinal (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)Check price on Amazon: Boom LoonaGo Portable Female Urinal (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)

How each works

A gel bag is a plastic bag with a super-absorbent polymer inside. TravelJohn says the polymer in its LIQSORB pouch absorbs 50 times its own weight in liquid and turns it into a gel, which the fabric pouch holds in. The maker of the roadbag describes thousands of polymer crystals under a fleece lining that turn urine into a firm gel that does not dissolve again. You pee into it, close it and put it in a bin.

A reusable urinal is a rigid bottle or jug with a lid. Men's bottles have a narrow neck; women's urinals have a wider, shaped opening. You empty it into a toilet and wash it.

A gel bag holds the urine as a gel and goes in the bin; a reusable bottle has a lid and is emptied into a toilet and washed. Our drawing, not to scale.

Capacity and spill risk

By their makers' figures, the Restop 1 holds 20 oz (about 590 ml), the LoonaGo 24 oz (about 710 ml), the TravelJohn Resealable 800cc (28 fl oz), the Carex Male Urinal has marks up to 32 fl oz (about 950 ml), and the roadbag holds 1,000 ml.

The two kinds stop spills in different ways:

  • Gel bags rely on the gel. TravelJohn says its pouch makes the bag spill-proof and leak-proof even if it is punctured. Restop adds a one-way valve, which it says prevents spills if a used bag is dropped.
  • Reusable urinals rely on the lid, so close it straight away. Continence Product Advisor, an independent site run by the International Continence Society, says a narrow-necked men's bottle can take a non-spill adaptor (Amazon search, affiliate link, opens in a new tab), which stops spills even if the bottle is tipped upside down, and that sachets of super-absorbent gel can be put in a urinal to soak up the urine.
How a gel bag works: pee into it, the absorbent turns the urine into a gel, then seal it and put it in a bin. Our drawing.

Hold it so gravity is on your side. Continence Product Advisor says most men's urinals work in most positions as long as the base points downwards, so the urine flows away from you. It also warns that a full urinal can be heavy and hard to manage with a weak grip.

Disposal: the bin, never the toilet

Close a gel bag and put it in a general waste bin. The makers agree: Restop says its bags can go in any bin, and the roadbag maker says to put it in the carry bag supplied and then in household waste. Do not flush one. The Consumer Council for Water, the water consumer body for England and Wales, asks everyone to flush only the 3Ps: pee, poo and paper. It puts the cost of clearing sewers blocked by wet wipes and other hygiene products in the UK at an estimated £88 million a year.

Outdoors, carry a used bag out to a bin. The first point in Leave No Trace's advice on waste is "pack it in, pack it out".

Empty a reusable urinal into a toilet. If you have to empty one outdoors, treat it as you would a pee: well away from water, paths and camps. Our guide to going to the toilet outdoors gives the distances by country.

Cleaning a reusable urinal

Continence Product Advisor says a urinal used by one person at home should be cleaned thoroughly with soap and water between uses, following the maker's instructions. Carex says its Male Urinal is easy to clean but not for use in an autoclave. Boom says to rinse the LoonaGo with warm water, swish it with warm soapy water for a deeper clean, and let it dry completely before you lock the lid.

Then clean your hands. The CDC says soap and water is best, scrubbing for at least 20 seconds, and to use a hand sanitiser with at least 60% alcohol if you have no soap and water. A small kit helps: the urinal or bags, tissues, a bag for used items and hand gel.

In a car: stop first

Never use either while you drive. The Highway Code, which applies in England, Scotland and Wales, says safe driving needs concentration (rule 148). TravelJohn says the same in its FAQ: do not drive while using its bags, and park in a safe place. Wherever you are in the world, stop first.

  • Stop somewhere safe and legal. You must not leave your vehicle in a dangerous position or where it causes an unnecessary obstruction (rule 242).
  • Not on a motorway's hard shoulder. You must not stop on the carriageway, an emergency area, the hard shoulder, a slip road, the central reservation or the verge except in an emergency (rule 271). Leave at the next services or junction: service areas are there for breaks (rule 262).
  • Plan breaks. The Highway Code recommends a break of at least 15 minutes after every two hours of driving (rule 91).
  • Passengers. You must wear a seat belt if one is fitted (rule 99). TravelJohn suggests that a woman in a passenger seat can raise herself slightly and brace her lower back against the seat back.

A toilet stop is often a short detour. For early starts and late arrivals, see our list of public toilets open 24 hours.

Men, women and children

  • Men can use a narrow-necked bottle such as the Carex, or any of the bags. Continence Product Advisor notes that men with a short or retracted penis, which is common after prostate surgery, may find the wider opening of a women's urinal easier.
  • Women need a shaped opening: the LoonaGo, a unisex bag such as the TravelJohn or Restop 1, or the ladybag (Amazon search, affiliate link, opens in a new tab), which its maker says holds 1,000 ml and can be used standing, sitting or squatting. Continence Product Advisor says no single women's urinal suits everyone, so you may need to try more than one. Another option is a funnel that directs urine into a bag or bottle: see our comparison of the Shewee and the GoGirl.
  • Children. TravelJohn says its TravelJohn Jr (Amazon search, affiliate link, opens in a new tab) holds 600cc (20 fl oz) and is sized for children, and the roadbag and ladybag maker sells them for boys and girls too. For toddlers, a travel potty may be easier.

If you often need to go urgently because of a bladder or bowel condition, a Can't Wait card can help you ask to use a staff toilet in a shop or café.

Which to choose

  • Choose gel bags for an emergency kit, the glovebox, a rucksack or a family car: they are flat, need no toilet to empty and leave nothing to wash. The TravelJohn Resealable is the all-rounder; the roadbag holds the most.
  • Choose a reusable urinal if you go often, for instance at night in a van or a tent, and you can empty it into a toilet within hours. The Carex Male Urinal and the LoonaGo need no refills.
  • Keep both if you drive a lot: a bottle where you sleep, a few bags in the car.

For more picks, including the Shewee Peebol and the Carex Female Urinal, see our guide to the best travel urinals.

The products compared

1. Best all-round gel bag

TravelJohn Resealable Disposable Urinal

A single-use bag with a LIQSORB pouch that turns urine into a gel, and a zip to close it afterwards. TravelJohn says its unisex adapter works for all genders, sitting or standing, with a spill guard to stop backflow.

Type
Single-use gel bag
Capacity
800cc (28 fl oz)
Who
Unisex adapter, sitting or standing
Spill control
Gel pouch, spill guard and resealable zip
Size
5 x 2 x 1 in folded (about 13 x 5 x 2.5 cm)
Weight
1.5 oz before use (about 43 g)
After use
Zip it shut and put it in a bin
Packs
3, 6 or 18, with wipes

Good

  • Flat and light: TravelJohn gives 1.5 oz and 5 x 2 x 1 in folded
  • Zip closure on top of the gel pouch, for carrying it to a bin
  • Wipes come in the pack

Bear in mind

  • Holds 800cc, less than the roadbag's 1,000 ml
  • A new bag for every use

Check price on Amazon: TravelJohn Resealable Disposable Urinal (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)Specs: TravelJohn: Resealable (TJ1N-C)

2. Biggest bag, for men and boys

roadbag Disposable Urinal

A pocket urinal from KETS GmbH in Cologne, Germany, with a rigid ring 5.5 cm across and a super-absorbent that holds 1,000 ml. It is made for men and boys; the same maker's ladybag has an oval opening and a handle, shaped for women and girls.

Type
Single-use gel bag
Capacity
1,000 ml (about 34 fl oz)
Who
Men and boys
Spill control
Super-absorbent turns urine into a firm gel
Size
12 x 7 x 1 cm (about 4.7 x 2.8 x 0.4 in)
Weight
44 g (about 1.6 oz)
Opening
Rigid ring, 5.5 cm across
After use
In the carry bag supplied, then household waste

Good

  • Holds 1,000 ml, the most of the bags here
  • A rigid 5.5 cm ring keeps the opening in shape
  • Comes with a hand wipe and a bag to carry it to the bin

Bear in mind

  • Made for men and boys: women need the ladybag
  • The maker's website is in German

Check price on Amazon: roadbag Disposable Urinal (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)Specs: KETS GmbH: roadbag, ladybag and superbag (in German)

3. Best bag with a one-way valve

Restop 1 Liquid Waste Bag

A urine-only bag with a wide opening and a semi-rigid rim, which Restop says suits men or women, and a one-way valve to stop spills if a used bag is dropped. Restop is moving to its Cleanwaste brand, so new packs may carry that name.

Type
Single-use gel bag
Capacity
20 oz (about 590 ml)
Who
Men or women: wide opening, semi-rigid rim
Spill control
One-way valve; polymers and enzymes gel the urine
After use
Any bin, says Restop
Packs
12 bags (4 packs of 3), with tissues

Good

  • One-way valve, which Restop says prevents spills if the used bag is dropped
  • Wide opening with a semi-rigid rim, for men or women
  • Tissues included

Bear in mind

  • 20 oz is the smallest capacity here
  • For urine only: the RESTOP2 is the version for solid waste

Check price on Amazon: Restop 1 Liquid Waste Bag (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)Specs: Restop: RESTOP1 disposable liquid waste bags

4. Best reusable bottle for men

Carex Male Urinal

A plain polyethylene bottle with a snap-on lid that stays attached, graduation marks up to 32 fl oz and a sturdy grip. For men who need one often: in a parked car, a van or a tent at night.

Type
Reusable bottle
Capacity
Marks up to 32 fl oz (about 950 ml)
Who
Men
Spill control
Attached snap-on lid
Material
Lightweight polyethylene
Positions
Can be used in several positions
After use
Empty into a toilet, then wash
Cleaning
Easy to clean; not for autoclave

Good

  • No bags to keep buying
  • The lid is attached, so it cannot get lost under a seat
  • Graduation marks, which Carex says are useful to measure output

Bear in mind

  • A rigid bottle takes more room than a flat bag
  • Has to be emptied into a toilet and washed

Check price on Amazon: Carex Male Urinal (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)Specs: Carex: Male Urinal

5. Best reusable urinal for women

Boom LoonaGo Portable Female Urinal

A female urinal made for use away from home, with sculpted silicone contours for the seal, a carry tab and a snap-lock lid. Boom advises using it standing or leaning, to avoid mess.

Type
Reusable female urinal
Capacity
24 oz (about 710 ml)
Who
Women
Spill control
Snap-lock lid
Size
4 x 7 x 3 in (about 10 x 18 x 8 cm)
Material
BPA-free medical-grade silicone and polypropylene
After use
Empty into a toilet, rinse, let it dry before locking the lid

Good

  • Snap-lock lid for carrying it until you can empty it
  • Wide opening for emptying and cleaning, says Boom
  • Grip works in either hand

Bear in mind

  • Boom advises standing or leaning, not lying down
  • Boom says to lock the lid only once it is completely dry

Check price on Amazon: Boom LoonaGo Portable Female Urinal (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)Specs: Boom: LoonaGo

Questions

Can I flush a urine gel bag?

No. Close it and put it in a bin. The Consumer Council for Water asks everyone to flush only pee, poo and paper.

How much does a disposable urine bag hold?

It depends on the bag. Of those here, the Restop 1 holds 20 oz (about 590 ml), the TravelJohn Resealable 800cc (28 fl oz) and the roadbag 1,000 ml, according to their makers.

Can I use a travel urinal while driving?

No. The Highway Code for England, Scotland and Wales says safe driving needs concentration. Stop somewhere safe and legal first. On a motorway, leave at the next services or junction: you must not stop on the hard shoulder except in an emergency.

Are there urine bags for children?

Yes. TravelJohn says its Jr bag holds 600cc (20 fl oz) and is sized for children. The maker of the roadbag sells it for boys as well as men, and its ladybag for girls as well as women.

How do I clean a reusable urinal?

Empty it into a toilet, then wash it with soap and water and follow the maker's instructions. Boom says to let the LoonaGo dry completely before you lock its lid.

On toiletnearest.com